Anonymous Mafia

loves umbrellas wrote:

Someone Else wrote:I make case and no one cares?

I suppose if we're supposed to treat our SA identities as sacred info, it's for some kind of setup reason and not just to stifle our curiousity or preclude meta arguments? So in that case this does constitute pretty blatant fishing, which is more vote-worthy than lurking.

##unvote
##vote STFU Dad!

The whole point of the game is that we don't know who anyone is. Everyone is a blank slate. Of course, posting trends and such can give insight to who someone is, and someone whos identity is known can be less of a threat than a complete unknown.

youth in asia wrote:

loves umbrellas wrote:

Someone Else wrote:I make case and no one cares?

I suppose if we're supposed to treat our SA identities as sacred info, it's for some kind of setup reason and not just to stifle our curiousity or preclude meta arguments? So in that case this does constitute pretty blatant fishing, which is more vote-worthy than lurking.

##unvote
##vote STFU Dad!

The whole point of the game is that we don't know who anyone is. Everyone is a blank slate. Of course, posting trends and such can give insight to who someone is, and someone whos identity is known can be less of a threat than a complete unknown.

But you don't find name fishing scummy?

Of course it can be scummy, but in a game like this everyone is curious and will probably end up fishing somehow or another naturally.

STFU Dad! wrote:

Someone Else wrote:I make case and no one cares?

Your case is retarded, and not nearly as good as the case on love umbrellas. Albeit, I will admit that my posts are pretty role-fishy, but that's 1) too easy of a case and 2) too blatant to be scum.

Are you saying that you yourself are "too blatant to be scum"? That is WIFOM if I ever saw it.

##vote STFU Dad!

a giant prude wrote:

STFU Dad! wrote:

Someone Else wrote:I make case and no one cares?

Your case is retarded, and not nearly as good as the case on love umbrellas. Albeit, I will admit that my posts are pretty role-fishy, but that's 1) too easy of a case and 2) too blatant to be scum.

Are you saying that you yourself are "too blatant to be scum"? That is WIFOM if I ever saw it.

##vote STFU Dad!

Yea well this is a bandwagon vote if I've ever seen one.

No action is ever too scummy to be scum, FYI

STFU Dad! wrote:Yea well this is a bandwagon vote if I've ever seen one.

Yes I guess by this definition every vote after the first is a bandwagon vote, so let's just vote each player once and end the day in a no lynch instead

a giant prude wrote:

STFU Dad! wrote:Yea well this is a bandwagon vote if I've ever seen one.

Yes I guess by this definition every vote after the first is a bandwagon vote, so let's just vote each player once and end the day in a no lynch instead

i think this is a terrible idea. no lynching day 1 sounds like a bad thing to do. are you a left hander, prude?
##unvote
##vote a giant prude

All this feels way too much like playing in mafiascum


i'm not voting stfu dad, i like voting nude towel boy it feels so good

A MODEST BLUNT wrote:No action is ever too scummy to be scum, FYI

WRAWNG

by the way namefishing isn't only scummy but annoying and against the spirit of the game jerkface

The 90s wrote:by the way namefishing isn't only scummy but annoying and against the spirit of the game jerkface

Against the spirit of the game? It may be vital to the mechanic of the game you jerkface.

Just wanted to post and say that you should quote this if you are a goatee fan. QTIYD

everyone vote youth in asia

The 90s wrote:All this feels way too much like playing in mafiascum


i'm not voting stfu dad, i like voting nude towel boy it feels so good

i hate this post because of all the

lumpenlistTM

scummy
you

thats all thats my lumpenlistTM

The 90s wrote:All this feels way too much like playing in mafiascum


i'm not voting stfu dad, i like voting nude towel boy it feels so good

no way we're on page 11 if this was mafiascum we'd be a month into the game already

Votecount for Day 1
STFU Dad! (3) - Someone Else, loves umbrellas, a giant prude
Possibly Left Handed (1) - A MODEST BLUNT, snuup dugg, snuup dugg
Nude Towel Boy (1) - The 90s, Goatee Enthusiast, Goatee Enthusiast
youth in asia (1) - A First Grader
loves umbrellas (1) - STFU Dad!
Goatee Enthusiast (1) - youth in asia
I Fucking Love Corn (1) - Possibly Left Handed
a giant prude (1) - snuup dugg

With 15 alive it takes 8 to lynch. Deadline is 11:59PM EST TONIGHT.

Yes I guess by this definition every vote after the first is a bandwagon vote, so let's just vote each player once and end the day in a no lynch instead

It's a bandwagon vote because you echoe'd what was already said and then dropped a vote.

a giant prude wrote: Are you saying that you yourself are "too blatant to be scum"? That is WIFOM if I ever saw it.

##vote STFU Dad!

The Creator: No disrespect, but that votecount is wrong. a giant prude is getting flack for a bandwagon vote on STFU Dad!, not Possibly Left Handed.

loves umbrellas wrote:

a giant prude wrote: Are you saying that you yourself are "too blatant to be scum"? That is WIFOM if I ever saw it.

##vote STFU Dad!

The Creator: No disrespect, but that votecount is wrong. a giant prude is getting flack for a bandwagon vote on STFU Dad!, not Possibly Left Handed.

Fixed, thanks!

People I'd like to hear more from:

Taxable Income: Why so quiet? Haven't heard a peep since you were making noise about a vigkill.
A Modest Blunt - We get it, you're funny. Any content forthcoming?
I Fucking Love Corn - I do, too.
HELP - You're not HELPing keep this game from going nowhere fast.
Nude Towel Boy - What did you mean by "It's a fair cop."?

What are all of your thoughts on namefishing, "too blatant to be scum" but not "too scummy to be scum" STFU Dad!?

Let's not have a no lynch kthx.

##unvote
##vote STFU Dad

CHUGGA CHUGGA CHUGGA CHUGGA CHUGGA CHUGGA CHOOOOOOOOOOOO CHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

whats the case on him anyway

Goatee Enthusiast wrote:Just wanted to post and say that you should quote this if you are a goatee fan. QTIYD

Quotin this

1. Hey STFU DAD you never replied to my guess on your identity!

2. Taxable Income, how about that vig kill eh? Want to speak up?

3. Somebody respond to this:

Goatee Enthusiast wrote:

youth in asia wrote:What we need is something to stir up discussion

Okay, how about this. How does this game work? Is this a regular game, except without the possibility of meta because it's all anonymous? Or how might knowing which SA players correspond to which players here affect the game?

* waits for somebody to call me scummy for discussing game mechanics